The Unlikely Ones Watch on YouTube
All stories Aboard the Titanic · 1912

Richard Norris Williams

The Legs a Doctor Wanted to Cut Off Won Olympic Gold

In April 1912 the 21-year-old tennis player Richard Norris Williams jumped from the sinking Titanic and spent hours knee-deep in freezing water. On the rescue ship a doctor wanted to amputate his frostbitten legs. He refused, kept walking until the feeling came back, and in 1924 won Olympic gold.

R. Norris Williams, portrait from J. Parmly Paret’s Methods and Players of Modern Lawn Tennis, 1915

Richard Norris Williams, known as R. Norris or “Dick” Williams, was born on January 29, 1891, in Geneva, to parents from Philadelphia. In April 1912 the 21-year-old tennis player was traveling first class on the Titanic with his father, Charles Duane Williams; both had boarded at Cherbourg.

When the liner struck an iceberg and sank, father and son jumped into the water as she began her final plunge. Williams’s father was killed by the first funnel to fall from the ship. In Williams’s own words, “I saw one of the four great funnels come crashing down on top of him.” He made his way to the partially submerged Collapsible A, a lifeboat that was “little more than buoyant platform,” in Mental Floss’s words, and held on to its side for quite a while before getting in. Then he spent several hours in it, knee-deep in the freezing water.

The ordeal left his legs so severely frostbitten that the doctor on the rescue ship, the Carpathia, wanted to amputate them. Williams was “stoutly against such a drastic medical procedure,” says the International Tennis Hall of Fame. Instead he worked through the injury, getting up and walking around every two hours, around the clock, and gradually the feeling returned to his legs.

Later that year he won his first US title, in mixed doubles with Mary Browne. He won the US National Championships in men’s singles in 1914 and 1916, and in 1920, with Chuck Garland, the Wimbledon gentlemen’s doubles. At the 1924 Paris Olympics, at 33 and with a sprained ankle, he won the gold medal in mixed doubles, partnering Hazel Hotchkiss Wightman. He went on to win the Davis Cup in 1925 and 1926, entered the International Tennis Hall of Fame in 1957 and died in 1968.

Watch on YouTubeSources and photo credits are below.

Fact check

The facts and where they come from

  1. A doctor wanted to cut off his frozen legs, but he refused. Wikipedia: “The ordeal left his legs so severely frostbitten that the Carpathia’s doctor wanted to amputate them.” International Tennis Hall of Fame: “When a physician aboard the Carpathia suggested amputating both of the legs,” and “Williams was stoutly against such a drastic medical procedure.” 12
  2. His name was Richard Norris Williams. Wikipedia calls him R. Norris “Dick” Williams and gives his birth as January 29, 1891, in Geneva, to Philadelphia parents. 1
  3. In April 1912 he sailed on the Titanic with his father. Wikipedia: “He and his father, Charles Duane Williams, were traveling first class on the liner when it struck an iceberg and sank.” His father’s Wikipedia article says both boarded at Cherbourg as first-class passengers. Mental Floss calls him “the 21-year-old.” 153
  4. As it sank, father and son jumped into the sea. Wikipedia: “As Titanic began her final plunge, father and son jumped into the water.” 1
  5. He watched a giant funnel crash down on his father. Wikipedia: “his father was killed by the first funnel falling from the ship,” and in Williams’s own words, “I saw one of the four great funnels come crashing down on top of him.” Mental Floss: “According to an unpublished account written by Williams, Charles was struck by a funnel from the ship that had broken off.” 13
  6. He swam to a half-sunk lifeboat and clung to its side. Wikipedia: “He made his way to the partially submerged Collapsible A, holding onto its side for quite a while before getting in.” Mental Floss: “Williams swam to a collapsible lifeboat that was little more than buoyant platform, gripping its side.” 13
  7. For hours he sat in it, knee-deep in icy water. Wikipedia: “After entering the lifeboat, he spent several hours knee-deep in the freezing water.” International Tennis Hall of Fame: “Williams’ legs were frostbitten from being submerged in the icy ocean for hours.” 12
  8. On the rescue ship Carpathia, a doctor wanted to amputate his frostbitten legs. Wikipedia: “the Carpathia’s doctor wanted to amputate them.” Mental Floss: “But he resisted the doctor’s pleas to amputate the appendages.” 123
  9. He said no. International Tennis Hall of Fame: “Williams was stoutly against such a drastic medical procedure.” Wikipedia: he “opted instead to work through the injury.” 21
  10. Instead he walked every two hours, day and night. Wikipedia: “simply getting up and walking around every two hours, around the clock.” Mental Floss: “Williams walked around the Carpathia every two hours, even at night, and gradually, feeling returned to his limbs.” 13
  11. Slowly, the feeling came back. International Tennis Hall of Fame: he “walked the deck until sensation returned.” Mental Floss: “gradually, feeling returned to his limbs.” 23
  12. That year he won a US national title. Wikipedia: “later that year, he won his first U.S. Tennis Championship, in mixed doubles.” At the 1912 U.S. National Championships, Mary Browne and R. Norris Williams won the mixed doubles over Eleonora Sears and William Clothier, 6–4, 2–6, 11–9. 16
  13. Then he won the US Championships twice. Wikipedia: “He won the U.S. National Tennis Championships in men’s singles in 1914 and 1916.” International Tennis Hall of Fame: he “won the first of two U.S. National Men’s Singles Championships in 1914,” and “Williams won his second U.S. Nationals title in 1916.” 12
  14. And Wimbledon, in doubles. International Tennis Hall of Fame: “With Chuck Garland, Williams earned the Wimbledon Gentlemen’s doubles title in 1920.” In the 1920 final, Garland and Williams beat Kingscote and Parke 4–6, 6–4, 7–5, 6–2. 27
  15. At 33, with a sprained ankle, he played the Paris Olympics. Wikipedia: “During the 1924 Olympics, at the age of 33 (and with a sprained ankle).” Mental Floss quotes Williams: “I had sprained an ankle badly in the semis.” Tennis Majors: the official report says he was “unable to give his best in the singles owing to a foot injury.” 134
  16. The legs a doctor wanted to cut off won him a gold medal. Wikipedia: he “became a gold medalist in the mixed doubles, partnering Hazel Hotchkiss Wightman.” International Tennis Hall of Fame: “winning a Gold Medal in mixed doubles at the 1924 Olympic Games in Paris, France with Hazel Hotchkiss Wightman.” For the gold, Wightman and Williams beat Marion Zinderstein and Vincent Richards. 128
  17. Later he won the Davis Cup in 1925 and 1926, entered the International Tennis Hall of Fame in 1957 and died in 1968 (Wikipedia). 1

Sources

  1. Richard Norris Williams Wikipedia
  2. Richard Norris Williams II International Tennis Hall of Fame
  3. The Star Tennis Player Who Survived the ‘Titanic’ and Went On to Win Olympic Gold (Jake Rossen, August 2, 2024) Mental Floss
  4. July 21, 1924: The day Titanic survivor Dick Williams won Olympic gold in Paris Tennis Majors
  5. Charles Duane Williams Wikipedia
  6. 1912 U.S. National Championships (tennis) Wikipedia
  7. 1920 Wimbledon Championships – Men’s doubles Wikipedia
  8. Tennis at the 1924 Summer Olympics – Mixed doubles Wikipedia

Notes

The jump: the International Tennis Hall of Fame and Mental Floss say he leapt forty feet (“published accounts report”); Wikipedia says only that father and son jumped into the water. We give no height.

How long in the water: “several hours” (Wikipedia), “for hours” (International Tennis Hall of Fame) or “an estimated six hours” (Mental Floss). We say several hours.

Both legs: the International Tennis Hall of Fame says the physician suggested amputating both legs; Wikipedia says “amputate them.” His reported words to the doctor (“I’m going to need these legs”) come from later retellings, and the Hall of Fame itself says “he reportedly said,” so we don’t quote them.

The 1912 title was the US mixed doubles, with Mary Browne.

Pictures: the portrait was published in J. Parmly Paret’s Methods and Players of Modern Lawn Tennis (1915). No photo of Williams in the water or on the Carpathia is known in the free record, so the sinking is shown in Willy Stöwer’s 1912 engraving, an artist’s impression, and the Carpathia photos show the ship and other survivors, not Williams. The Titanic photo was taken as she left Southampton on April 10, 1912. The tennis photos come from other years of his career: practicing in 1913, at Forest Hills about 1915–16, and with the Davis Cup team in the 1920s (the Library of Congress record gives no year), where the negative’s caption names the players “Tilden – Johnston – Richards – Williams,” left to right. The Olympic photo was published in Le Miroir des Sports in 1928.

Photo credits

The archive photos in this story

All the photographs and illustrations in this story are in the public domain. Tap one to enlarge it, or follow the link to its Wikimedia Commons page for the full record. The narration, captions and graphics in the Short are our own; its music and sound effects are credited below.

Music and sound effects

Music: Debussy, La Mer: III. Dialogue du vent et de la mer (US Air Force Band, Concert Band, public domain, US government work); Brahms, Symphony No. 2 in D major, Op. 73: IV. Allegro con spirito (Musopen Symphony Orchestra, CC0).

Sound effects: Freesound, CC0.

More stories

Vietnam · 1968 Roy Benavidez

Zipped Into a Body Bag, Still Alive

Sources & photo credits
At sea · 1911–1916 Violet Jessop

Miss Unsinkable

Sources & photo credits
Space · 1970 Apollo 13

Houston, We’ve Had a Problem

Sources & photo credits
Antarctica · 1915 Ernest Shackleton

The Ship Crushed by Ice

Sources & photo credits
Okinawa · 1945 Desmond Doss

The Medic Who Refused to Carry a Gun

Sources & photo credits
The Moon · 1969 Apollo 11

The Landing That Almost Didn’t Happen

Sources & photo credits
South Carolina · 1863 Harriet Tubman

The Raid That Freed More Than 750

Sources & photo credits
New York · 1860 Grace Bedell

The Girl Who Told Lincoln to Grow a Beard

Sources & photo credits
Charleston · 1862 Robert Smalls

Past Fort Sumter in the Captain’s Straw Hat

Sources & photo credits
Argonne Forest · 1918 Cher Ami

Shelled by Their Own Guns, They Sent a Pigeon

Sources & photo credits
Iwo Jima · 1945 Jack Lucas

The Stowaway Who Covered Two Grenades

Sources & photo credits
Richmond · 1849 Henry “Box” Brown

Nailed in a Box, Shipped to Freedom

Sources & photo credits
Iran to Scotland · 1942–1963 Wojtek the Bear

The Bear Who Was Enlisted as a Private

Sources & photo credits
Berlin · 1936 Jesse Owens and Luz Long

The Rival Who Hugged Jesse Owens

Sources & photo credits
Alaska · 1925 The 1925 Serum Run

The Dog Who Ran the Most Dangerous Leg

Sources & photo credits
Niagara Falls · 1901 Annie Edson Taylor

Over Niagara Falls in a Barrel, at 63

Sources & photo credits
Tokyo · 1925–1935 Hachikō

The Dog Who Waited Almost Ten Years

Sources & photo credits
New Orleans · 1960 Ruby Bridges

Four Marshals Walked Her Into First Grade

Sources & photo credits
Indian Territory · 1875–1902 Bass Reeves

The Lawman Who Took the Warrant for His Son

Sources & photo credits
Rome · 1960 Wilma Rudolph

From a Leg Brace to Three Olympic Golds

Sources & photo credits
Kaunas · 1940 Chiune Sugihara

Told Not To, He Wrote Visas by Hand

Sources & photo credits
Yale to France · 1917–1918 Stubby

Smuggled to France in a Coal Bin

Sources & photo credits
Arctic Ocean · 1909 Matthew Henson

Forty-Five Minutes Ahead of Peary

Sources & photo credits
Tuscumbia · 1887 Helen Keller and Anne Sullivan

Water, Spelled Into Her Hand

Sources & photo credits
Korea · 1952–1953 Sergeant Reckless

Bought for $250, Promoted to Staff Sergeant

Sources & photo credits
Pearl Harbor · 1941 Dorie Miller

He Fired a Gun He Was Never Trained to Use

Sources & photo credits
Cleveland · 1916 Garrett Morgan

The Real Inventor Posed as the Sidekick

Sources & photo credits
Chicago to France · 1920–1921 Bessie Coleman

Refused at Home, She Learned to Fly in France

Sources & photo credits
Warsaw · 1942–1943 Irena Sendler

She Buried the Children’s Names in Jars

Sources & photo credits
Albany, New York · 1888–1897 Owney

The Stray Who Rode the Mail Around the World

Sources & photo credits
Brooklyn · 1947 Jackie Robinson

He Promised Not to Fight Back

Sources & photo credits
Lubang Island · 1944–1974 Hiroo Onoda

The War Ended in 1945. He Stopped in 1974.

Sources & photo credits
Indiana to Oregon · 1923–24 Bobbie the Wonder Dog

Lost in Indiana, He Walked Home to Oregon

Sources & photo credits
Stockholm · 1912 Jim Thorpe

Stripped of His Golds Over Baseball Pay

Sources & photo credits
Pacific War · 1942–1945 The Navajo Code Talkers

Their Language Became a Code Nobody Broke

Sources & photo credits
Yangtze River · 1949 Simon the Cat

The Wounded Ship’s Cat Who Won a War Medal

Sources & photo credits
Hollywood · 1942 Hedy Lamarr

The Movie Star Who Invented Between Takes

Sources & photo credits
France · 1918 Henry Johnson

He Fought Off German Raiders With a Knife

Sources & photo credits
New York City · 1854 Elizabeth Jennings

A Century Before Rosa Parks, She Sued and Won

Sources & photo credits
Civil War · 1861–1865 Mary Edwards Walker

Stripped of Her Medal, She Wore It Anyway

Sources & photo credits
Cape Canaveral · 1961 Ham the Chimp

The Chimp Who Flew to Space Before Any Human

Sources & photo credits
Montreal · 1899 Major Taylor

Banned at Home, He Became World Champion

Sources & photo credits
Blackwell’s Island · 1887 Nellie Bly

She Faked Insanity to Expose an Asylum

Sources & photo credits
Sicily · 1943 Chips the Dog

The Hero Who Lost His Medals for Being a Dog

Sources & photo credits
NASA Langley · 1962 Katherine Johnson

John Glenn Trusted Her Over NASA’s Computers

Sources & photo credits
Fort Wagner · 1863 William Carney

He Was Shot but Wouldn’t Give Up the Flag

Sources & photo credits
Around the World · 1894–1895 Annie Londonderry

Barely a Cyclist, She Set Off Around the World

Sources & photo credits
Lyme Regis · 1823 Mary Anning

Shut Out of the Meeting on Her Own Find

Sources & photo credits
Dunkirk · 1940 Charles Lightoller

The Titanic Survivor Who Took His Boat to War

Sources & photo credits
Cavendish, Vermont · 1848 Phineas Gage

An Iron Bar Shot Through His Head. He Lived.

Sources & photo credits
Holtzwihr, France · 1945 Audie Murphy

He Fought Alone on a Burning Tank Destroyer

Sources & photo credits
Europe · 1940–1945 “Mad Jack” Churchill

He Went to War With a Sword and a Longbow

Sources & photo credits
Toledo · 1884 Moses Fleetwood Walker

In the Majors 63 Years Before Jackie Robinson

Sources & photo credits
North Atlantic · 1912 Margaret “Molly” Brown

She Begged Her Titanic Lifeboat to Go Back

Sources & photo credits
Argonne Forest · 1918 Alvin York

His Draft Card Said “Don’t Want to Fight”

Sources & photo credits
Great Barrington · 1781 Elizabeth Freeman

She Heard “Born Free” and Sued Her Owner

Sources & photo credits
Central Pacific · 1942 Eddie Rickenbacker

America’s Top Ace Was Saved by a Seagull

Sources & photo credits
Tarrytown, New York · 1782 Deborah Sampson

She Dug Out Her Own Bullet to Keep Her Secret

Sources & photo credits
Shenandoah · 1942–1977 Roy Sullivan

Lightning Hit Him Seven Times, and He Survived

Sources & photo credits
Corinth, Mississippi · 1862 Old Abe

The War Eagle the Confederates Wanted Dead

Sources & photo credits
Balaclava, Crimea · 1855 Mary Seacole

Refused as a War Nurse, She Went Anyway

Sources & photo credits
Central Pacific · 1943 Louis Zamperini

He Survived 47 Days on a Raft. Then It Got Worse

Sources & photo credits
Chickamauga · 1863 John Clem

He Went to War at Nine and Retired a General

Sources & photo credits
Cascade, Montana · 1895 Mary Fields

Born Enslaved, She Carried Montana’s Mail in Her Sixties

Sources & photo credits
Kingston, New York · 1828 Sojourner Truth

She Took a White Man to Court to Win Back Her Son

Sources & photo credits
Lyon, France · 1941 Virginia Hall

She Crossed the Pyrenees on a Wooden Leg Named Cuthbert

Sources & photo credits
Germany · World War II Joseph Medicine Crow

He Came Home From World War II a Crow War Chief

Sources & photo credits
Macon, Georgia · 1848 Ellen Craft

She Escaped Slavery Disguised as a White Master

Sources & photo credits
Antietam, Maryland · 1862 Clara Barton

A Bullet Through Her Sleeve Killed the Man in Her Arms

Sources & photo credits
Iwo Jima · 1945 Ira Hayes

The Iwo Jima Flag Raiser Who Never Felt Like a Hero

Sources & photo credits
Baltimore, Maryland · 1838 Frederick Douglass

He Escaped Slavery on Another Man’s Papers

Sources & photo credits
Western Front · 1914 The Christmas Truce

The Night the Trenches Sang

Sources & photo credits